Osegi
Science·2 min read

School phone bans add one to two weeks of learning, study finds

A study of 3.3 million students finds school phone bans add the equivalent of one to two weeks of learning. Researchers now want to test phone use at home.

A student's smartphone locked inside a lockable pouch on a classroom desk.
Image: The Verge

Do school phone bans actually work? A new US study says yes, modestly. Banning phones in class has the same effect as adding one to two weeks to the school year, according to researchers from Harvard University and Dartmouth College working with the assessment group NWEA.

That is roughly half of the learning loss US students suffered between 2013 and the 2020 covid-19 pandemic. The team analyzed test data from 3.3 million students at 4,600 schools, covering the 2021–22 to 2025–26 school years, with and without bans. Tom Kane, faculty director of Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research, says a modest effect is exactly what they were looking for.

Earlier research often looked at schools outside the US, and an earlier US study used school averages. This one used student-level data, which let the team control for more factors. The effect was similar across age groups and achievement levels, which surprised Kane.

Are school phone bans cost-effective?

The researchers say yes. Lockable pouches for a class of 17 would cost about $425 per teacher. Paying an average teacher for an extra week would cost $2,080.

What about phone use outside school?

Kane suspects out-of-school use may explain part of the remaining loss, and some of the gaps between lower and higher achievers. There is no ban to test that, but he sees one chance. This summer Meta agreed to a $17.1 billion settlement with nearly every US state, including sweeping limits for users under 18. Many take effect within months, and by default they cap teens' time on Meta's apps.

That could give researchers a before-and-after comparison. There are two problems. The settlement gives no easy way to check whether teens really use Meta less, or just move to other apps. Researchers would also need to link the limits to school achievement. Attorneys general are encouraged to strike similar deals with TikTok and YouTube, which have declined so far. Kane says platforms could share de-identified, aggregated data by school.

"I spent the whole summer trying to identify other sources of data for this, and I just struck out," Kane says.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:school phone banmeta settlementharvardnweaeducationsocial media

More from this day

See all →

More in: Science

See all →