Osegi
Security·2 min read

San Diego ends Flock camera contract and smart streetlights

San Diego's city council voted to drop Flock and Ubicquia, switching off 500+ plate-reading cameras it approved just three years ago with the mayor's backing.

A smart streetlight with a mounted license plate reader camera above a San Diego street at dusk.
Image: Ars Technica

San Diego is switching off its Flock cameras. On Monday evening the city council voted to end its contracts with two surveillance vendors, Flock and Ubicquia, only three years after the mayor and other city leaders urged the council to approve the program.

Flock, a startup with an estimated valuation of $8.3 billion, makes AI-driven automatic license plate readers (ALPR), cameras that log the plates of passing cars. Ubicquia supplied the so-called smart streetlights that worked together with Flock's software. Both go. San Diego is one of the largest cities to cut ties with Flock. Mayor Todd Gloria said he "respect[ed] the Council's decision" and would not veto it.

Why did San Diego drop Flock?

The turning point came last month, when councilmember Stephen Whitburn withdrew his support. "If Flock cameras are causing many San Diegans to feel unsafe, then they have lost effectiveness as a public safety tool," he said at an October press conference. That opened a majority for ending the program.

Lilly Irani of the TRUST SD Coalition, a longtime critic, credited a national mix of left, right and centre opposition. Pegah Parsi, a member of the city's Privacy Advisory Board, which had urged the council to vote the 2023 plan down, wrote on LinkedIn that she now feels "vindication."

What does Flock say?

Flock says it respects the decision but argues "public safety moves backward" without the tool. At the meeting, police said vehicle theft has fallen 20 percent since 2023 and that the cameras helped recover 689 stolen vehicles.

Not the first streetlight U-turn

This is the second time in under a decade that San Diego has tried smart streetlights and dropped them. The city bought thousands of systems from GE Current, which a previous mayoral administration shut down in 2020. Ubicquia later acquired that smart city platform and proposed the 500-camera setup with Flock in 2023.

Secure Justice, an Oakland advocacy group, says it has documented at least 513 Flock contracts that have ended nationwide. Its executive director, Brian Hofer, said Americans "do not consent to their government tracking them as we go about our daily lives."

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:flock safetysan diegosurveillancelicense plate readersubicquiasmart streetlights

More from this day

See all →

More in: Security

See all →