Osegi
Science·2 min read

Little Red Dots: could Webb's mystery objects be Big Bang black holes?

Hundreds of tiny red lights in James Webb images have puzzled astronomers. A new study asks if some are black holes born before the first star.

Infrared James Webb Space Telescope view of a distant galaxy cluster with a few tiny red dots of light scattered among the galaxies.
Image: t3n Magazin

The James Webb Space Telescope keeps finding tiny red lights in the young universe, the so-called Little Red Dots, and nobody agrees on what they are. A new study says some could be black holes that formed in the first fractions of a second after the Big Bang.

The work, published in Physical Review Letters, comes from researchers at Johns Hopkins University, the Space Telescope Science Institute in Baltimore and the University of Padua. Ordinary black holes are the leftovers of burned-out stars. Primordial black holes, a idea Stephen Hawking floated in the 1970s, would have collapsed directly from dense clumps of matter before any star existed.

What is Abell 2744-QSO1?

The test case is Abell 2744-QSO1, about 13.1 billion light-years away, seen as it was roughly 700 million years after the Big Bang. A galaxy cluster in front of it acts like a magnifying glass and shows it three times. At its centre, gas circles a black hole of around 50 million solar masses, at least twice as heavy as all the surrounding stars combined. Today a central black hole is typically about a thousandth of its galaxy's stellar mass. The surroundings are almost pure hydrogen and helium, so few stars can have lived there.

How could a Big Bang black hole get that big?

The team ruled out two routes. Black holes born with millions of solar masses would have left marks in the cosmic microwave background, the radiation echo of the early universe, and satellite data show none, so the starting weight was at most about 1,000 suns. Thousands of small ones merging also fails in nearly all models, because the collisions kick the merged object away.

One path survived: a roughly 1,000-solar-mass black hole feeding on hydrogen and helium for hundreds of millions of years, with almost no new stars forming in its gas disk. That fast feeding would also puff up the inner disk and trap X-rays, which fits why Little Red Dots give off so few.

Is it proven?

No. The study offers no observational proof, and many of the roughly 100 catalogued Little Red Dots probably hold ordinary black holes. Rivals include young black holes wrapped in dense gas, called black hole stars, and direct collapse of huge gas clouds. Co-author Loris Del Grosso says the study only opened a door that was already ajar a bit wider. Proof would need an object that clearly formed before the first stars, or one lighter than any collapsed star could be.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:james webblittle red dotsprimordial black holesbig bangastronomystephen hawking

More from this day

See all →

More in: Science

See all →