Osegi
Crypto·2 min read

Ethereum has 'no terms of use,' judge says, clearing MIT brothers

A federal judge says Ethereum has no terms of use, and that a 2023 trade against trading bots involved no lie. Two MIT brothers walk free of a $25 million fraud case.

A courthouse exterior with a blurred Ethereum logo overlay, representing the federal ruling that cleared two brothers of crypto fraud.
Image: CoinDesk

A U.S. federal judge has said, in effect, that you can't break the rules of Ethereum when Ethereum has no rules to break. Brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, accused of a $25 million fraud, have been acquitted.

The judge ruled that the brothers' 2023 trade against Ethereum trading bots involved no lie that anyone relied on. Fraud needs a deception, and without one the charge fell apart. In the judge's words, Ethereum has "no terms of use."

The ruling closes the U.S. government's first criminal case over MEV.

What is MEV, and why was it a criminal case?

MEV stands for maximal extractable value. In plain terms, it is the money that can be made by controlling or exploiting the order in which transactions are processed on a blockchain such as Ethereum. Automated bots hunt for these openings constantly, and the 2023 trade at the center of this case was made against such bots.

Prosecutors treated that trade as fraud. It was the first time the U.S. government had taken the practice to a criminal court, which is why the outcome was watched closely by people who build and trade on Ethereum.

What the acquittal means

The decision does not say that every move on a blockchain is fine. It says that in this case, the government could not point to a lie that a victim relied on. That is the core of a fraud charge, and the judge found it missing.

For the brothers, it ends a case that had put a $25 million fraud allegation over two people with MIT backgrounds. For everyone else, it is a data point on how far U.S. criminal law will stretch to cover behavior on open, permissionless networks, where there is no company, no contract and no terms of service to point to.

This was the first criminal case of its kind, and it ended without a conviction.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:ethereummevperaire-buenofraud casecourt ruling

More from this day

See all →

More in: Crypto

See all →