Osegi
Mobile·2 min read

Epic vs Apple: 122,000 documents allegedly withheld, fines sought

Epic Games says Apple is sitting on more than 122,000 documents about its proposed App Store link-out fees, and wants the court to fine Apple for every day it stalls.

The Apple logo and the Epic Games logo side by side in front of a courthouse, illustrating their App Store legal dispute.
Image: 9to5Mac

Epic Games says Apple has 122,000 documents it hasn't handed over, and wants a judge to start charging Apple a fine for every day that continues. The documents, according to Epic, would show how Apple came up with the commission it wants to charge on App Store link-outs.

What Epic says Apple is holding back

In a new filing, Epic accuses Apple of repeatedly failing to produce papers explaining how it arrived at its proposed rates. Apple has suggested commissions of 5% to 15% on purchases made through external payment links, a proposal it submitted on August 13. Epic is expected to respond once Apple finishes producing documents.

Epic's numbers are striking. Searching the files of four people Apple says decided on the fee (Tim Cook, Eddy Cue, Carson Oliver and new CFO Kevan Parekh), plus three other key figures (Nate Barton, Alex Roman and Phil Schiller), turned up hits on agreed search terms such as "proffer", "contempt", "injunction" and "link-out". Apple produced 632 of those documents and is withholding over 122,000 as irrelevant, which Epic calls "bogus". That is well over 99%.

Epic also says the production holds no substantive email on the rates, no notes from meetings where they were decided, no internal financial analysis, no App Store profit and loss statements, and nothing backing Apple's claim that link-out costs are "essentially zero".

What does Epic want the court to do?

Epic wants Apple ordered to hand over every non-privileged document matching the agreed search terms by December 2, 2026, whatever Apple thinks of its relevance. Apple could still screen for attorney-client privilege, and Epic would sort out what matters. Epic proposes no dollar figure, only a daily sanction for each day after that date.

Background

The fight goes back to Epic's 2020 lawsuit. In 2021 Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ruled Apple must let developers point users to outside payment options. Apple allowed links but charged up to 27%, and the court found Apple in civil contempt. Apple is appealing, and the dispute has reached the Supreme Court.

The discovery hearing was set for November 24, but a new, not yet public order sends the dispute to a magistrate judge and cancels the deadlines and hearings.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:epic gamesappleapp storelawsuitlink-out commission

More from this day

See all →

More in: Mobile

See all →