Osegi
Web & Dev·2 min read

Quad9 is leaving France on 24 November after a court order

Quad9, the free 9.9.9.9 DNS service, will stop answering users in France on 24 November rather than block pirate streaming sites. Cloudflare says the court is wrong.

Illustration of a DNS resolver server with a French flag and a blocked connection symbol.
Image: Numerama

Quad9, the free DNS resolver at 9.9.9.9, will stop working for people in France on 24 November 2026. The Swiss nonprofit behind it would rather leave the country than block pirate streaming sites on a French judge's order.

On 21 October, the Paris judicial court fined the foundation 1,000 euros a day for ignoring a blocking order won by beIN Sports. The Qatari broadcaster wanted Quad9 to stop translating the domain names of sites that stream tennis matches illegally into IP addresses, until 14 November. Quad9 says it cannot reliably tell who is in France, and it refuses to push a French court's decision onto users worldwide.

Why is Cloudflare criticising the ruling?

On 17 November, Cloudflare, which runs its own public resolver at 1.1.1.1, called the departure a "canary in the coal mine". It accepts that rights holders have a legitimate interest in fighting piracy, but says DNS resolvers are "the wrong approach".

Its comparison: a resolver is a phone book. Striking an illegal shop from the book does not close the shop. The pirate content stays online, and anyone can get around the block "in less than a minute" by switching resolver. Blocking also hits whole domains, so legal content on them disappears too, with no explanation for the user. Cloudflare also warns that one country could end up deciding what the whole world can reach. It suggests going after the hosts of the pirated files instead.

Swedish company Mullvad has also called the order "a system of censorship" and urged French users of its browser who picked Quad9 for encrypted DNS to change their settings.

What happens to people still using Quad9 in France?

In France, Quad9 is used by individuals, but also by public bodies, schools, hospitals and energy suppliers. The foundation keeps no data that identifies its users, so it cannot warn them. Anyone who has not switched resolver by 24 November will see their connection "simply stop working", with no error message.

Cloudflare may be next. In Belgium, an order threatens Cloudflare, Google and Cisco with heavy penalties if they do not start blocking sites through their public resolvers by early January 2027. All three have appealed. In Spain, LaLiga has blocked thousands of shared Cloudflare IP addresses on match days since December 2024, cutting millions of people off from legitimate sites.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:quad9cloudflarednsfrancepiracybein sports

More from this day

See all →

More in: Web & Dev

See all →