Osegi
Gaming·1 min read

PlayStation Store lawsuit thrown out by UK tribunal over £2bn claim

A UK tribunal dismissed the £2 billion PlayStation Store price case against Sony, saying physical games and rival consoles gave players real alternatives.

A PlayStation 5 console and controller next to a physical game case on a shelf.
Image: Engadget

A UK tribunal has thrown out the PlayStation Store lawsuit that accused Sony of overcharging millions of players. The reason is a little awkward: the judges pointed to physical discs as competition, just as Sony plans to phase them out for new games.

On Tuesday the UK competition tribunal dismissed the class action, which sought £2 billion ($2.6 billion) in damages. Consumer advocate Alex Neill filed it in 2022 on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners. It argued that Sony's control of the PlayStation Store let it take a 30 percent cut, and that games would be about 20 percent cheaper without that grip. Had it won, eligible players could have received around £162 ($214) each.

Why did the tribunal reject the PlayStation Store case?

The tribunal said players had other options: physical copies and rival consoles. It called the idea that they were trapped in a closed ecosystem "not credible" and rejected the claim that games would have been 20 percent cheaper. In its words, "there was strong evidence of a willingness of consumers to switch consoles following an increase in games prices."

It also leaned on Sony's own research, which warned the company would lose business if its prices weren't competitive with Xbox.

Sony's defence was that supporting third-party storefronts would be prohibitively expensive and would hurt security and performance.

What happens to the physical games argument?

That is the irony. Sony is planning to phase out physical copies of new PlayStation games, and the future of Xbox is, to put it kindly, murky.

The same tribunal came to the opposite conclusion about Apple last year. In a similar case, it found that the App Store's 30 percent cut on digital sales was an abuse of dominance.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:sonyplaystation storeclass actionuk tribunalantitrust

More from this day

See all →

More in: Gaming

See all →