Osegi
Security·2 min read

Plane sound geolocation: how unheard aircraft reveal a video's location

Two propeller planes too far away to hear were enough for a YouTuber to pin down where a silent-looking camera clip was filmed. Open-source copies appeared within two days.

Spectrogram showing curved Doppler traces of a propeller plane above a quiet river and trees seen by a security camera.
Image: 01net.com

A security camera clip showing only trees and a river. No landmarks, no voices. Yet two propeller planes that nobody could hear were enough to work out where it was filmed. That is the claim of video maker Colsto, and the idea behind this kind of plane sound geolocation is already being copied.

On 2 November, Colsto, who specialises in geolocating footage from public clues, posted a 29-minute video titled "I discovered a sound that leaks your exact location". Knowing only the country and the day of recording, he says he found the spot to within about a hundred metres.

How can a plane you can't hear give away your location?

It comes down to the Doppler effect, the same thing that makes an ambulance siren drop in pitch as it passes. Aircraft engines do it too, even several kilometres away. Low sounds travel far, and a phone or camera microphone picks them up when your ear doesn't. On a spectrogram, a visual map of an audio file's frequencies, each flyover draws an S-shaped curve showing the plane's speed, its closest distance and the exact moment it passed.

The second half is public data. Nearly all aircraft broadcast their position, altitude and speed through ADS-B, and hobbyist networks archive it. Colsto spotted two flyovers 920 seconds apart and derived about 70,000 candidate locations. He dropped those where a third plane should have been audible, leaving roughly 15,000. He then simulated the curve each would produce and compared it with the real one. One spot matched, and Street View showed the same line of trees, camera pole included.

There is a catch: he has not released the original audio or his code, so the hundred-metre figure is unverified. The principle has precedent, though. Forensic experts have long dated recordings by matching the hum of the electrical grid to utility archives.

Copies appeared within two days

Within two days, at least eight open-source projects reproduced the method, some built by AI coding agents. One finds Colsto's challenge clip to within 86 metres, searching the whole United States. It needs two flyovers and a start time accurate to two minutes. With one plane or a vague time, the tools fail or give up, and public webcams they tested blind were never located.

There is a side effect for AI video. On 3 November, Adam Holter had OpenAI's Codex check 120 AI-generated clips and reported none contained a plane Doppler curve. It only works one way, he admits, since most real videos lack one too. A curve matching a flight logged that day would suggest a real recording, until generators learn to fake it.

Europe has required ADS-B only since 7 December 2020, and only for aircraft above 5.7 tonnes or faster than 250 knots, so many small propeller planes escape. All successful cases so far involve US recordings, and the community archive only goes back to 2023.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:geolocationdoppler effectads-bcolstovideo forensicsai-generated video

More from this day

See all →

More in: Security

See all →