Osegi
Gaming·2 min read

GTA VI violence feels too real for players, IShowSpeed included

IShowSpeed knocked an elderly woman off her scooter in GTA VI and instantly regretted it. Players say Rockstar's realism makes pointless violence hard to enjoy.

A streamer reacting in horror at a GTA VI scene on screen, with a scooter crash in a sunny Florida-style street.
Image: xataka.com

The day before GTA VI launched, IShowSpeed, one of the most-followed streamers on the planet, knocked an elderly woman off her scooter in the game. He regretted it on the spot. He felt sorry for her. That reaction is new for a series where this kind of thing used to carry almost no moral weight.

He is not alone. An X user called GUMSHOE posted another streamer's clip of a shootout at a daylight intersection and wrote that the realism "has gone too far". It stops being funny, the post said, when you see the same thing every day while scrolling or watching the news.

Why does GTA VI violence feel different?

The panic around GTA is old. In May 1997 a Scottish lord took an unreleased game about robberies and running people over to the House of Lords. In 2013 GTA V caused a stir with "By the Book", a mission where you torture a man. In 2020 the American Psychological Association wrote that there is not enough scientific evidence of a causal link between violent games and violent behaviour.

What has changed is us. When Charlie Kirk was killed in September 2025, videos of the shooting reached millions within minutes, including people who were not looking for them. In a 2024 study commissioned by Ofcom, young people described online violence as unavoidable and named recordings of real school fights among the most common things they saw.

Rockstar built Leonida, the game's Florida, out of that viral material. The first trailer, from December 2023, recreated viral Florida videos almost shot for shot. If the game looks like phone footage, its violence reads like phone footage too.

How does Rockstar handle violence in GTA VI?

Rob Nelson, co-director at Rockstar North, said in an interview that players can threaten, knock someone out, or shoot without killing. In Focus mode, lethal spots are marked red and joints yellow, and a yellow marker means an enemy is incapacitated but alive. Crowds flee when a weapon comes out, and the protagonist is no longer the only armed person on the street. Violence is more chaotic and rewards the player less.

There is also a Criminal Profile. According to Nelson, it ignores what a mission or self-defence requires but punishes players who go "beyond what is necessary" repeatedly.

Psychology has measured this guilt for years. Studies from 2010 found players feel guiltier when virtual violence has no justification, especially empathetic ones. It may not last: Matthew Grizzard found that replaying a violent game reduces the guilt, and the effect carries over to other games.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:gta virockstar gamesishowspeedvideo game violenceleonida

More from this day

See all →

More in: Gaming

See all →