Osegi
Mobile·2 min read

GrapheneOS accuses Google of pressuring Android makers

GrapheneOS says Google is leaning on phone makers just as Motorola becomes the first brand to officially support it. Google has not yet answered the claim.

A smartphone showing the Android robot logo, held in a hand against a dark background.
Image: xataka.com

GrapheneOS, the privacy-focused Android alternative, has accused Google of pressuring phone manufacturers, and the timing is hard to miss. Motorola is about to become the first brand to offer official GrapheneOS support, on its Signature 27.

What is GrapheneOS claiming?

GrapheneOS is built on AOSP, Google's open-source version of Android. It ships without Google apps or services, because Google doesn't allow them to be preinstalled on uncertified Android phones. Its focus is privacy and security, and until now it only ran on Pixel phones, the only devices that met its security requirements.

In a long Mastodon thread, the developers argue that Google has been closing Android step by step. They list harder ROM installs, obstacles to distributing apps outside the Play Store, penalties for unlocking the bootloader and a changed pace for AOSP releases. They call it sabotage.

They add that this could break US law and the EU's Digital Markets Act. Alphabet is a designated gatekeeper under that law, and Android, AOSP included, is one of its core platform services. The EU has already forced Google to open Android to other AI assistants, with a deadline of July 2027, and to allow alternative payment methods in Google Play.

Why the 4.125 billion euro fine matters

In July, the EU's Court of Justice finally upheld a 4.125 billion euro fine against Google for using Android to hurt rivals. One of the practices involved requiring certified manufacturers not to sell phones running unapproved Android versions. After that, Google had to allow forks in Europe. What GrapheneOS describes now looks a lot like it.

The thread landed alongside two announcements. Google confirmed that developer verification will reach the whole world from January 2027, and Motorola opened US reservations for the Signature 27.

A caveat: GrapheneOS offers no evidence of the pressure and doesn't name the manufacturers involved. Its alarms haven't always been right either. In August it wrote off the Pixel 11 over missing MTE, a memory security feature, and in November confirmed they will be supported after all. The original reporter has asked Google about the claims and is waiting for a reply.

Custom ROMs are already a niche. LineageOS has 1.6 million active installs against more than 3.8 billion Android users, under 0.1%.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:grapheneosgoogleandroidmotorolaaospdma

More from this day

See all →

More in: Mobile

See all →