Osegi
Mobile·2 min read

Apple answers Epic over 122,000 documents: 'NFL Commissioner'

Apple says Epic's search terms matched the NFL Commissioner and words like 'feeble', which is why it did not hand over 122,000 documents in the App Store fee fight.

An Apple Store sign beside a gavel, illustrating the court dispute between Apple and Epic Games over App Store commissions.
Image: 9to5Mac

Apple's defence against claims that it hid 122,000 documents from Epic Games includes a surprising exhibit: the NFL Commissioner. Apple says Epic's search terms were so broad that they dragged in documents about American football, and even the word "feeble".

The dispute is part of the wider Apple Epic court fight over App Store commissions. While the Supreme Court is set to review whether the civil contempt finding against Apple should stand, the two companies are also arguing in district court over what fee, if any, Apple can charge on purchases made through external payment systems. Apple filed its proposal on August 13, asking for commissions between 5% and 15%.

Epic had asked for 16 categories of documents, including internal analyses of the financial impact of those commissions. Apple agreed to use Epic's search terms and cover all the named employees. Last Friday, Epic told the court that Apple was holding back more than 122,000 documents that matched those terms from seven initial employees, and asked for all non-privileged matches to be handed over.

Why does Apple say the search terms were too broad?

Apple's answer is about wildcards, the asterisk that makes a search match any word starting with a given prefix. Epic's "commission*" caught government and private commissions, plus "commissioner", including the NFL one. "fee*" matched "feel", "feed", "feedback", "feet" and "feeble" without "fee" or "fees" appearing at all.

Apple says at least 95% of that document pool never mentioned "link-out" (the term for linking users to outside payment) or its variations. It also says the sweep caught personal tax and medical records, passwords, unannounced products, investor materials and privileged legal communications. Its legal argument is that a party must produce responsive documents, not everything a search string returns.

What happens next?

Apple says reviewing and redacting the documents would make Epic's proposed December 2 deadline impossible. It wants the motion rejected. If the court wants to step in, Apple suggests a randomized, statistically significant sample of the documents it considers nonresponsive go to a Special Master for independent review, instead of going straight to Epic.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:appleepic gamesapp storelink-out feescourtdiscovery

More from this day

See all →

More in: Mobile

See all →