Osegi
Web & Dev·2 min read

Facebook is not 'free' if you pay with data, EU adviser says

For years Facebook's homepage promised it was free and always would be. An adviser to the EU's top court now says paying with your data means it isn't.

A smartphone showing the Facebook logo with a price tag made of data symbols hanging from it.
Image: Frandroid

"It's free and always will be." If you used Facebook before 2019, you saw that slogan splashed across the homepage. Laila Medina, an advocate general at the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), says it was misleading and clashes with EU law.

In an opinion issued on 19 November 2026, Medina wrote that "a social network is not free when you pay with your data to use it." The case was brought against Meta by a German consumer protection association.

Why does Facebook's "free" claim matter?

Medina relies on the EU directive on unfair commercial practices. Her view is that handing over personal data for commercial purposes can be a form of payment, even if no money changes hands. That data has economic value for the operator of a social network, she says.

Her reasoning is that limiting "payment" to cash would weaken consumer protection in the digital economy, where users may not know what their data is worth or how far it is used for advertising.

Complying with the GDPR, Europe's data protection law, does not solve this, she adds. The unfair practices directive still applies. Only data processing needed to provide the service or meet legal obligations falls outside the rule.

Can companies still offer services for data?

Yes. Medina says businesses remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data. What they can't do is describe those services as "free" when that exchange is required. And the fact that users keep their data doesn't change this: using it commercially still counts as payment, she argues.

What happens next?

An advocate general's opinion doesn't bind the CJEU, and the court could go another way later. In practice, though, the judges usually end up aligned with it. If they follow Medina, the "free" label that sits on much of the European web could become a legal problem for any service paid for with data.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:facebookmetacjeugdprconsumer protectionpersonal data

More from this day

See all →

More in: Web & Dev

See all →