Osegi
Mobile·2 min read

App Store synth app rejections: Unfiltered Audio hit four times

A synth developer says Apple rejected his iOS app four times, once over a term a reviewer allegedly misread as audio tech. Is AI behind App Store reviews?

A musician's iPad running a synthesizer app next to a MIDI keyboard on a desk.
Image: ギズモード・ジャパン

Apple's App Store review has a new complaint from the music world: synth apps that get rejected for reasons developers say make little sense. The most detailed account so far comes from Unfiltered Audio, a company known for high-quality AUv3 plugins (the format that lets instruments run inside other iOS music apps).

Michael Hetrick of Unfiltered Audio wrote on the Loopy Pro forum that the iOS release of Sinusoidal Run Rhythm (SRR) was rejected four times. First, Apple asked for a demo video, which he says happens with almost every one of the company's plugins. Second, a reviewer reportedly "hallucinated" that "polyharmonic" was a piece of audio technology and demanded proof of a licence to use the word in the description. Third, Apple again asked for a video of the app connected to "required dedicated hardware". Fourth, SRR MIDI was flagged as spam because it resembles SRR.

Another developer described the same pattern: the status goes from "waiting for review" to "in review" to "rejected" almost instantly. It looks automated, he says, and nobody seems to have read what he wrote.

Does Apple use AI in App Store review?

Yes, in part. Apple said in May this year that it uses AI to quickly spot complex malicious patterns and analyse app similarity, so human reviewers can focus on what matters. Whether that explains the SRR rejections is unknown. Nobody outside Apple can confirm it.

Why are reviews slow?

AI-assisted "vibe coding" has reportedly pushed a flood of new submissions into the App Store, and many developers say it has stretched review times. Apple says the average review takes 1.5 days. Developers describe a different experience.

For musicians, the stakes are practical. iOS has plenty of synths good enough for live and studio work. If strong apps get stuck in review while the store fills with quick, AI-built ones, the people hurt most are the small teams who made the good stuff.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:appleapp storeapp reviewaisynth appsunfiltered audio

More from this day

See all →

More in: Mobile

See all →