Osegi
AI·1 min read

AI weapon detector in US schools flags binders and water bottles

A Wi-Fi based AI weapon detector meant to protect US schools keeps flagging binders and metal water bottles as weapons. Schools are getting their money back.

A school backpack with a binder and a metal water bottle sitting beside a security scanner at a school entrance.
Image: telepolis.pl

An AI weapon detector installed in American schools has a problem: it keeps mistaking binders and metal water bottles for weapons. The schools, at least, are getting their money back.

The idea sounded neat. The system uses ordinary Wi-Fi. A signal is disturbed differently depending on the shape and material of whatever it passes through, so as a student walks in, a plain router can in theory "see" whether they are carrying a weapon. No bulky metal-detector gates, no bag searches.

Before large sums were spent and the system was placed in many schools, its makers assumed two things. First, that it would make mistakes at the start. Second, that the AI would learn quickly to pick out dangerous objects and ignore everything else, reaching an accuracy of 95%.

How accurate is the school weapon detector?

The first assumption held up. The second did not. According to curator Dr. Mark Holtzman, he cannot say what the system's exact accuracy was, but it was not anywhere near 95%. In practice the detector still reports binders, metal water bottles and a long list of other everyday school items as weapons.

That is the awkward part of a security tool that guesses. Every false alarm means a stopped student, a delayed line and staff who learn to doubt the alerts. Backpacks are full of the kind of objects that confuse a system built on signal distortion.

Will schools get their money back?

Yes. The one clearly good piece of news is that the schools are due a refund of the money they put into the system.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:ai weapon detectorschoolswifi sensingfalse alarmsschool security

More from this day

See all →

More in: AI

See all →