Osegi
Security·2 min read

Outage or cyberattack? How to tell when the internet breaks

Five IT failures hit the US in four business days, and plenty of people suspected hackers. Analysts say only about one in a thousand outages is an attack.

A network operations screen showing red outage alerts across a map of the United States.
Image: Ars Technica

Five big IT failures in four business days is enough to make anyone suspect a cyberattack. A Microsoft Exchange outage hit thousands of companies, a Federal Aviation Administration technical problem grounded planes, a software issue disrupted JPMorgan Chase, United Airlines had another system glitch, and a classified NSA network went down, leaving staff at Fort Meade waiting at home.

With the US at war with Iran and fears of AI-enabled hacking rising, plenty of people read the pile-up as more than coincidence. So far, though, there is no evidence that these failures are linked, or that hackers caused any of them.

The starting point for analysts is simple: assume an accident. Doug Madory, head of Internet analysis at Infoblox, watches up to a dozen network outages a day. Only around one in a thousand, he says, turns out to be the work of hackers. Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince calls most of what he sees right now "standard background noise." João Tomé of IPinfo says the usual culprits are a bad update, a configuration change, a cable cut or a power failure.

How can you tell if an outage is a cyberattack?

First, check what the affected organisations say. Big companies post updates on verified social media accounts and in the newsroom section of their sites. Many also run status dashboard pages, which show which parts of a service are working. AWS, Google Cloud and Microsoft Azure all have one.

The picture can be muddy. A failure at a cloud provider such as Amazon Web Services can knock over its customers. Some services only look broken because they depend on one that is down. This week's bank trouble seems to be an example: several banks had problems, but all of them involved transactions with JPMorgan Chase. False reports can pile more confusion on top.

Second, look at independent network data. Amanda Meng of Georgia Tech, who helps run the Internet Outage Detection and Analysis service (IODA), points to its data, plus Cloudflare Radar and Watch the Net. Her team looks at when an outage began and ended and which networks were affected, then compares that with news reports. Madory also posts his findings on social media.

The short version: unless there is concrete evidence of an attack, treat it as a mistake.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:outagecyberattackcloudflareinfobloxiodamicrosoft exchange

More from this day

See all →

More in: Security

See all →