Osegi
AI·1 min read

ECHR bars lawyer over AI-hallucinated precedents in her brief

For the first time, the European Court of Human Rights has thrown a lawyer out of a case because her filing was full of AI-invented precedents.

The European Court of Human Rights building in Strasbourg, where a lawyer was excluded over AI-generated false precedents.
Image: heise online

A lawyer filed a brief at the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg. It cited precedents that, in effect, came from an AI. Now the court has excluded her, the first time it has done so for this reason.

The filing was full of what the tech world calls hallucinations: answers from a language model that sound plausible and authoritative but are simply made up. In a legal brief, that means case law that looks real and is not.

Why do AI hallucinations matter in court?

A brief is built on earlier rulings. Judges and opposing parties are expected to be able to look up what a lawyer cites. If a cited decision does not exist, the document is worthless at best, and it wastes the time of everyone who has to check it. That is presumably why the Strasbourg court chose exclusion over a polite reminder.

The exclusion is a notable step because the ECHR is one of Europe's most prominent courts. It hears complaints from individuals who say a state has violated their rights under the European Convention on Human Rights.

What happens next?

The material available so far does not name the lawyer or the case, and it does not say what the exclusion means for her client. What it does show is that courts are starting to treat unchecked AI output as a professional failing, not as a harmless slip. Anyone who files with a tool like ChatGPT has to read the sources themselves.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:echrai hallucinationslegal techchatgptcourts

More from this day

See all →

More in: AI

See all →