Osegi
Other·1 min read

BGH on AI-written court filings: unchecked ones can sink an appeal

Germany's Federal Court of Justice says a lawyer who lets AI draft an appeal brief and doesn't check it risks having the appeal thrown out as inadmissible.

A lawyer's desk with a laptop showing AI-generated text next to legal documents and a gavel.
Image: heise online

Letting an AI write your appeal and filing it without a proper read-through can cost you the appeal itself. That is the message from Germany's Federal Court of Justice, the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH).

According to the court, anyone who has the grounds for an appeal on points of law (a Revisionsbegründung) generated by artificial intelligence and submits it unchecked runs the risk that the appeal is inadmissible. In plain terms: the court may never look at the merits, because the filing doesn't count as a valid appeal.

Why AI-generated court filings are a problem

A Revision is the appeal in which a higher court reviews whether the law was applied correctly. Such appeals have formal requirements, and the written grounds are a core part of them. The BGH's point is that an AI tool does not take over the responsibility for that text. The person who files it does.

The summary of the decision does not spell out the details of the case or which specific shortcomings led the court to its view, so those are not covered here.

What it means for lawyers and their clients

AI drafting tools are increasingly used for legal writing. The BGH signal is that using them is not the issue. Submitting their output without verification is. For clients, the practical risk is a lost appeal, not just an embarrassing typo.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:bghailawcourt filingsgermany

More from this day

See all →

More in: Other

See all →