Osegi
Business·2 min read

Apple heads to a Paris court in 2027 over iPhone repair limits

Apple will be tried in Paris in June 2027 for allegedly obstructing iPhone repairs. The case targets parts pairing, which ties each component to the phone's serial number.

A technician replacing the screen of an iPhone on a repair workbench with small tools laid out beside it.
Image: Numerama

Apple will stand trial in Paris in June 2027, accused of making iPhone repairs harder than the law allows. It is the first time a French prosecutor has used this particular offence to bring a case.

The complaint comes from the French group HOP (Halte à l'obsolescence programmée), which filed it on 7 December 2022. After four years of investigation, the Paris prosecutor decided to pursue Apple. A first scheduling hearing is set for 25 February 2027, with several days of arguments in June 2027.

What is Apple accused of?

Not of slowing down iPhones on purpose, and not of building them to die early. HOP made those claims too, but the trial rests on a narrower offence: obstructing repair and reconditioning, written into article L441-3 of the French consumer code in 2021. It bans techniques, software included, meant to make repairs outside a maker's approved network impossible, or to limit what a phone can do once repaired elsewhere. According to HOP's press kit, 24 iPhone models are covered, between 17 November 2021 and 23 July 2024. The court will have to establish intent, not just a restriction.

The focus is parts pairing. Each component, such as the screen, battery, camera or Face ID sensor, has a serial number the phone links to its motherboard. If a part is swapped without validation through Apple's online tool, the iPhone shows an "unknown part" message and can switch off features like True Tone or the battery health display.

Apple's defence

Apple cites security and technical needs. Face ID and Touch ID talk to the chip's secure enclave, and screens and batteries need calibration. Since iOS 18, pairing also flags parts from phones locked by Activation Lock, which makes stripping stolen iPhones less profitable. Apple also points to its Self Service Repair programme, open to French users since December 2022, and a programme for independent shops. Critics note that parts cost almost as much as a repair at an Apple Store, where an out-of-warranty iPhone 18 Pro screen is 405 euros.

Apple told Numerama it "strongly contests these unfounded allegations". The risk is a fine of up to 5% of revenue, compensation for consumers and publication of the ruling. In HOP's earlier case on slowed iPhones, Apple paid 25 million euros in 2020 to settle with the DGCCRF, the consumer watchdog, over misleading commercial practice, with no trial.

Apps worth a look

SUMO: the number puzzle

Tap the right tiles, add them up, hit the target. Easy to learn, hard to master. Free, for all ages.

Tags:appleiphoneright to repairfrancehopparts pairing

More from this day

See all →

More in: Business

See all →